Egyptian Aak: Week 7


(Cairo, Qubba Palace clashes by AFP’s Mohamed El Shahed and DNE’s Ahmed AlMalky)

Main Headlines







 A  Few Thoughts

Defiant Brotherhood:

In an interview with CNN, opposition figure El Baradei said, “I don’t want Morsi to step down.” El Baradei added, “ he [Morsi] can reform himself.”

While El Baradei urges Morsi to “reform,” The front page of Freedom & Justice Party paper on the February 11 summarizes the Muslim Brotherhood’s mindset: “2 years after Mubarak stepped down,the counter revolution fails.” In other words, “We are here to stay.”

In addition to the ongoing Brotherhoodization of Egypt, President Morsi and the Muslim Brotherhood wanted to send a strong message that they  were not willing to compromise. Support from Prime Minister Qandil and the current government and Friday’s rally “against violence” are part of this strategy. Although the Brotherhood announced only a symbolic support for the rally, a prominent member of the Brotherhood Al-Beltagy spoke at the rally. The aim of this rally was not just to blame the opposition, but Islamists also wanted to create a perception of “perfect protests” that are well organized, peaceful, and thug free.

 This perception is fundamentally flawed; Islamist rallies are non-violent because they are member-only rallies. Each participant is expected to conform to a desired code of conduct (which is currently non-violent). Non-members are welcome to join only if they adhere to the same code; otherwise, “informal thugs” within the organized group will deal with them promptly. Opposition rallies by nature are completely different, as they focus on enticing all of the non-Morsi protestors to join in; many are angry, unemployed youth with simmering grievance, exactly as Islamists youth were during the Mubarak era. In short, the Islamist rally mainly aims to show off, while the opposition rally tries to force a change.

 The problem for the opposition is not just that their rallies have become synonymous with violent confrontation, but also the dwindling numbers of participants and the changing dynamics among the various groups that participate. Both Monday’s demonstration on the anniversary of the overthrowing of Mubarak and Friday’s protest at Qubba palace were marked by minimal participation, and I also find Wael Eskander’s account about the Ultras very disturbing. Whether they like it or not, the stigma of violence and unpopularity has started to catch the opposition, and it will be difficult to shake it up. They have fallen into the Brotherhood’s trap, and ordinary Egyptians will think twice before joining a violent protest.

The future of protest

It’s time for the opposition to give protest a tactical rest – it is overused and, frankly, pointless. Instead, it should focus on forging a wider alliance against the Brotherhood, even if that includes agreement with Salafi parties, like Nour, whose members are no longer willing to give Morsi an easy ride. The political outcome of this is by far more substantive than what protests can achieve at this stage of the struggle. As Ibrahim El-Houdaiby aptly explain: “opposition forces should focus on what they would do if the Brotherhood didn’t exist, to present an alternative the people can believe in.” I think we should not be over optimistic about today’s meeting between the Brotherhood’s Katatni and ElBaradei. I doubt that one meeting will bridge the wide gap between the two sides. If anything, this meetings indicates that the brotherhood leadership is worried by the ongoing deliberations between Nour party and the non-Islamist opposition.

A question of narrative?

I read several interesting remarks this week about Egypt, one of which was made by Marc Lynch. In his piece about Egypt’s policy challenge, he described (within a different context), a “liberal narrative.” Aside from my pedantic insistence that the opposition bodies in Egypt are non-Islamists rather than liberals, I genuinely think the problem is not in the narratives, but in core definitions. Islamists and non-Islamists disagree on what is black and what is white; no wonder consensus is a mirage. The struggle is confrontational in nature until one side scores a clear winner.


The main serious obstacle Morsi and the Brotherhood face is the economy and its steady decline. What remains to be seen is how they will solve the economic conundrum ahead of a parliamentary election that they aim to win in an outright majority. The government’s plan B look very unconvincing. The U.S. Ambassador Patterson highlighted many of Egypt’s Complex issues, she rightly pointed out that Egypt needs to make peace with its past. judging with how our politicians and “scholars” behave, and bearing in mind that there are very few pigs in Egypt, I think it is fair to say “when camels fly.”

Good Read

Finally, here is Jayson Casper’s prayer for Egypt

About nervana111

Doctor, blogger and Commentator on Middle East issues. The only practising doctor who write in Middle Eastern politics in UK.
This entry was posted in Diary of Aak, Egypt and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Egyptian Aak: Week 7

  1. I like the valuable information you provide you with on your content articles.I’ll bookmark your blog website and look at yet again listed here consistently.I am somewhat guaranteed I’ll learn a whole lot of new things best listed here! Fantastic luck for the future


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s